A Question of Scale

I’ve had a couple of Airfix 1/76 buildings for a while and have finally got around to painting one up. My intention was to use these for my 1/72 Chain of Command games, but it turns out the buildings are on the small side for 1/76, and start to look absolutely tiny for 1/72.

Now, that’s not necessarily a problem-underscale buildings work well in lots of wargaming applications, but it DOES make them less that ideal for 1/72 skirmish gaming, where being able to fit an entire squad of panzergrenadiers in a building becomes important.

On the happy side of things, these buildings look absolutely perfect with my 18mm Napoleonics, which are, eventually, going to do double duty as skirmish figures for Sharp Practice, before moving on to proper unit basing for Neil Thomas’s Napoleonic rules set. The buildings are still small, but at 18mm (AKA swole-up 15mm), they just look like modestly sized structures, rather than something from a dwarf village.

Here are some shots to compare with. Modeling for you on the left are some AB British Peninsular Light Infantry, done up as the 52nd Oxfordshire. On the right are a couple of AB 20mm WWII US Infantry figures.

Airfix 1:76 European Country Cottage Ruin. I think this is meant to be Second Empire Style?

Airfix 1:76 European Country Cottage Ruin. I think it is meant to be in Second Empire Style? I still haven’t weathered this thing, and it definitely doesn’t belong in Normandy, but it will hit the table today for a game of Chain of Command, anyway! If I had it to do over again, I think I’d have left the photo-etched window mullions off of the model. They look a bit weird.

Airfix Italian Farmhouse. Definitely not getting any 20mm figures mounted on pennies on that front porch!

Airfix 1:76 Italian Farmhouse.  Definitely not getting any 20mm figures mounted on pennies on that front porch!

——–

All that out of the way, these buildings are extremely well sculpted, feature a lot of detail, and are cast in a high quality resin. Very little cleanup was required on the cottage, which made it a real delight to work up, compared to my previous efforts with a JR miniatures resin building. The Italian Farmhouse should be equally easy to prep for painting.

The backs of these buildings are knocked out, which makes it very easy to place figures inside, without having to fool with taking off a roof or 2nd floor.  A nice touch for the wargamer. Potentially bizarre for the dioramist. Looking at some of the damage patterns on the buildings, I question the sculptor’s knowledge of the way structure works, but that’s not really a problem, is it?

One potentially serious omission is that neither building has a first floor. This means you’re definitely going to need to base the houses, and scratch build a floor (with lots of rubble scatter), if you want them to look right. That’s not an insurmountable challenge, or anything, but it’s something to take into account, if you’re after a ready-to-go solution.

I think the buildings were $20-25, or thereabouts, which, even taking into account my quibbles, seems like a good price for the quality of product you receive.

 

Advertisements
Post a comment or leave a trackback: Trackback URL.

Comments

  • grantdyck  On 06/07/2014 at 10:05 am

    I really like the airfix white resin buildings. My church was from that line, and by changing the doors, it for with 28mm!

    • arkiegamer  On 06/07/2014 at 10:26 am

      Well, there’s a thought-modifying the door lintels for a particular scale.

  • Frank Arey  On 06/11/2014 at 8:45 pm

    Glad to see the reference to Neil Thomas Napoleonic rules. That project isn’t dead – just on summer break!

    • arkiegamer  On 06/11/2014 at 10:03 pm

      “Sometimes, I wonder what I’m gonna do
      But there ain’t no cure,
      For the summertime blues”

      I actually got out my Portuguese the other day and looked at them. No paint was applied, though.

  • arteis  On 09/20/2016 at 6:30 pm

    The top one isn’t Second Empire, but rather it’s a Dutch farmhouse – very typical style for the Netherlands. I’m going to add a foundation underneath the walls, but leaving a gap for the door – this will make the door look taller, so it’ll work for my 28mm figures (hopefully!).

You know what to do

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: